德国ME Geithain 极品喇叭901 (补图)

二手器材 >>音箱

发布者: 任我行 来 自: 218.79.77.120
发布时间: 2006-06-07 21:06:10 付款方式: 支付宝
到期时间: 两年 成色:
价格: 220000RMB 运输公司: 顺丰快递
销售地点: 讨论 返回本版
评述:
Musikelectronic Geithain RL-901


[Italian version]
Product: Studio Reference Monitor Loudspeaker RL-901
Manufacturer: Musikelectronic Geithain, Nikolaistrasse 7, D-04643 Geithain, fax
+49.(03.43.41)3.11.44
Test sample: auditioned at local distributor's


The fall of the Berlin Wall has brought us, audio-wise, two good things from
East-Germany. One of these you know already, our resident cable-loonie Thorsten
Loesch; the other you're about to be acquainted with now.

Enter Musikelectronic Geithain, a small (13 employees) loudspeaker
manufacturer, situated in the picturesque village of ... Geithain, and deep
into quality professional audio since, oh, the sixties. Not just pro-audio. No.
Uncompromised pro-audio. Headed by Joachim Kiesler, musician, director, and
instrument-builder, not to mention engineer, Geithain made its quest the quest
for perfect neutrality. And for perfect dynamics.

And so, after a small-scale start, the company grew. And its speakers grew, in
size and in ambition. Implementing improvement after improvement. And the
factory grew, now including a large anechoic room as well as a rather unique
reference room for multi-channel reproduction.

These people do not know the verb 'to compromise'. Safely tucked-away in behind
the Iron Curtain, these people simply tackled any problem encountered by
investigating it, and then by bluntly eliminating it.

As you already would have thought by now: ME Geithain make all of their
components in-house, according to their own ideas, and rooted in their own
decades-old experience. Perhaps that a few years isolation from the western
world is not a bad thing in hifi!

Or is it? Other things indicate that ME-Geithain also has remained wrapped-up
in professional audio lore, and hence that they have not been receptive to some
of the valid new findings originating from the audiophile community. Perhaps
the future can bring a bit of cross-fertilisation?


Speaking of Speakers

The RL-901 is Geithain's biggest model except one, being a massive and
forbidden-looking black cube of 55 x 50 x 43 cm, weighing in at a mean 48 kg -
each - and housing a full three-way system based on a 40 cm woofer in a closed
box, 12 cm inverted-dome midrange and a dome tweeter. All of this
manufacturer's loudspeakers are active models, this particular one relying on
one 180W and two 100W (ref. 4 Ohms) class AB amps and associated crossovers
working at 550Hz and at 2.8kHz. The line input feed is balanced only, and the
RL-901s feature no adjustable settings for tonal balance: this model is the
reference model, to be used in large, acoustically-treated locations such as
classical music studios, rooms which have to be optimised for the speakers,
rather than the other way around. But do note that Geithain's smaller models,
all active as well, feature adjustable settings for bass and treble balance.



The other salient point is that these are quasi-coaxial loudspeakers: midrange
and tweeter sit on a small metal baffle which is suspended in front of the bass
cone. This baffle is so wide that it makes it impossible for the tweeter
to 'see' the woofer, at once a solution to a basic problem of most other
coaxials. The midrange cone is not loaded by a box, but rather its rear output
is dissipated in a pack of absorbent mounted right behind it. Time-alignment of
the mid and top drivers relative to the bass driver is done in the active
crossover circuitry. This gives the speaker a coherent phase behaviour over
most of the spectrum. By the way, talking about spectra, the anechoic response
of the RL-901 is flat within 5dB from 25Hz to 20kHz. And better, even its 45
degree horizontal off-axis response still is commendably flat. Which all
together makes us expect something extra-ordinary when it comes to imaging,
not?

But what about the RL-901s own 'image'? Well, suffice to say that they are
ugly. Very ugly. Though of course the manufacturer would point out that they
were not made to look at anyway, so what the heck are we nagging about? (We are
nagging about marketability...)


Listening to Speakers

With my eyes wide shut I auditioned these speakers in a highly curious system
comprising Sony XA-50ES CD transport, the mighty LFD DAC-3 (did you know it was
LFD who made analogue doyen SME's digital-to-analogue converter, a classy
component that never saw commercial life?), the just-as-migthy LFD balanced
passive preamp with its switched-resistor attenuators, long runs of some non-
descript interconnect cable, and then the RL-901s with their low 10kOhms input
impedance. Such systems ought not to work, but then again, in quality audio the
only hard rule is that there are no hard rules, and the local distributor
swears with the LFD pre for 'the taming influence it brings to the speakers
undomesticated bass'.



The black boxes were positioned 1.5m from ground level in their matching studio
frames, perhaps 4 m wide, and well enough from any walls. The room featured RPG
Acoustics bass traps throughout: a necessity in what is otherwise a troublesome
place.

Normally I don't really like big loudspeakers. Exceptions to this rule are
Jamo's Oriels, big ATCs, and the Apogees of yore, but in general things like
Wilsons and giant Acapellas are not quite my cup of thea. This just as an intro
to me having to say that I found the RL-901s remarkably easy to listen to: they
sound dynamically explosive, very 'real', with a loose subterranean bass and
lots of tiny details everywhere, but they're also quite natural and indeed lack
the edge and sizzle normally associated with studio-class monitoring speakers.

Starting with Cassandra Wilson's New Moon Daughter, we got a full-bodied
overall presentation, with raspy trumpet to the left decaying into the far-
away, at the same time the double-bass, drum and guitar breaking loose to the
far right. Trumpet and rhythm section clearly playing together, but not unduly
influencing each other. Oh, and in the middle Cassandra standing. Of course.

In the mid-bass a slight booming or oooh-sound manifested itself, which was
kind of strange and unexpected initially, given Geithain's obsession with
neutrality. After some consideration we concluded this had to be a room
anomaly: the floor was largely undamped, so a direct reflection of the woofer's
sound and resulting interference at the listening position, situated at around
170Hz or so, could well have done this: the high Geithain stands may be suited
to near-field studio monitoring, for long-range listening in a living room they
are less than ideal, not to mention that they are in fact also less than
rigid... (Oh, and more than ugly !-)

Going over to the Dead Can Dance disc, the audience was protrayed
realistically. The bells starting track one loud, penetrant, cristalline. In
the good sense of the words. Further there was no grain, no aggression, again
that ooh-sound in the bass, but also a very wide and rather deep soundstage,
with decent rhythmical behaviour throughout.

Monteverdi was rendered in a very colourful way, with rasping brass, playful
flutes, and full-bodied voices.

Mary Black sounded open, with in the track Columbus that one lone cymbal far to
the right finely differentiated. With many other speakers or systems this
particular cymbal sounds just like a grey tizzzz. The strings at the end of the
song were really resin-like, the RL-901 giving here a performance as good as I
remember it from the wonderful Apogee Caliper Signature ribbon speakers.

Staying with a cello, Yo-Yo Ma's sounded warm, grumbling, gracious. Probably
like Bach intended it, which is not a bad thing.

And then the Walkabouts delivered a deep and full bass (less dry than the B&W
Nautilus 801s), with good voices (though there was a little bit of friction on
sibilants), fingers touching guitar strings and fretboards. Open, wide,
layered, with the strings being an entity on their own, playing with the rock
band, coherently.

And the Loreena McKennitt disc, which sounded so awfully thin on the B&Ws, now
did much better again, with indeed pretty good vocals!

A brief spell with an active preamp from JDI gave an even more dynamic (read:
thunderous) sound, with explicit bass and treble, but overall I found the LFD-
sourced music more natural.

If fatigue could set in after a few hours of listening, then it was not due to
any inherent problems with these speakers, but rather because of the listening
levels which were higher than what I am used to. The Geithains simply invite
you to crank the volume!


Little Brother



Later on I also had the chance to audition the much smaller RL-904s. These are
an active pseudo-coaxial two-way design, not larger than your average stand
mounter, but still with an anechoic response that is commendably flat between
40Hz and 20kHz, and each with two 100W amplifiers built in. In the midrange and
treble they sounded similar to their much bigger brothers, only a little bit
thinner, less open, but just as controlled and dynamic. It was amazing what
kind of bass came out of their tiny 12 cm woofers: obviously a result of their
active equalization and drive which gives good extension, but at the same time,
and perhaps expectedly so, the bass also could sound a bit processed and
opaque. Clearly, these speakers, at their price of e5000, are a viable solution
when one demands neutral, powerful and dynamic speakers which at the same time
must be small. For audiophile types, though, the same kind of money buys more
balanced and musical speakers. Which then are bound to be more than a bit
taller, of course.


Conclusions

These Geithains excel in every parameter one seeks in huge speakers: extension,
neutrality, dynamics, grandeur of sound. Futhermore, we have here a loudspeaker
system that, while perhaps not so extremely detailed, still in many respects,
and especially in sheer listenability, surpasses the also-big B&W 801 / Krell
combination I tested earlier (but please note that such statements are very
system-dependent, and prospective buyers always should listen for themselves),
and this at less than one third of the package price: surely something to be
applauded.

Now if only the manufacturer could bring us the same sound in a less
aesthetically challenged package ...
图片: 图片1    图片2    图片3    
回复人: whitelight 来 自: 221.222.195.75
回复时间:: 2006-06-08 03:35:35 讨论 返回本版
评述: Amazing price in 220k!
Congra in trade!
  • 共1个1/1页